Electronics Forum | Tue Jun 14 10:48:03 EDT 2005 | Paul
We evaluated several machines a couple of years ago and ended up selecting an Agilent SJ50. Fast machine but very limited on joint inspection. Also does not detect missing components reliably which you would normally take as a given on an AOI system.
Electronics Forum | Wed Jun 08 10:32:27 EDT 2005 | rlackey
We ran an MVT 1820 Supra against a VT-Win-II for around 40K high density boards. One machine was 1/3 of the price of the other, more accurate in production, faster, and could handle larger boards. Guess which won? Fortunately we were able to loo
Electronics Forum | Fri Jun 17 17:11:59 EDT 2005 | stansmt
I have been working with the Yestech system in my facility after evaluating the Mirtec. The yestech system has far less false calls and better defect coverage based on the test vehicles I ran. The YTV-1000 out performed the Mirtec in defect detection
Electronics Forum | Sun May 29 11:42:45 EDT 2005 | Stephen
I will say that AOI units are not > magic boxes, you get out of them what effort you > put into them. Use them as process improvement > devices, not a magic machine to catch all your > mistakes. Mirtec's come close though, but you are right a
Electronics Forum | Thu May 26 18:55:15 EDT 2005 | bakersm
I have been comparing Mirtec to Yestech on a regular basis. As a AOI trainer and installer, I have seen significant difference between the machines. 1. In a side by side comparison just today, using the same board, I found the following: a. Insp
Electronics Forum | Fri May 27 18:46:09 EDT 2005 | gregcr
I am almost hesitant to mention my good fortune with our Yestech system, for fear that our advantage in the industry will be known. We have run a Yestech for about a year, the operator interface is very well organized. Data is scanned on the machin
Electronics Forum | Thu Jun 02 11:22:13 EDT 2005 | Rob
Hi Kyle, Although I agree in principle with what you say, we were getting exellent solder joint inspection on reasonably high density boards (approx 1000 components from 0402 to finepitch QFP's). However obviously they wouldn't touch any form of BG
Electronics Forum | Fri May 26 09:43:52 EDT 2006 | smteng0201
We looked at YESTech and found that they not only lowered their inspections scores to decrease their high false call rate, but more importantly they missed actual failures. In the big picture, I would rather have the chance to look at something and
Electronics Forum | Mon Jun 20 16:48:24 EDT 2005 | Steve
Although I am sure that some of the postings here are legitimate, it is obvious that many of them have been written by AOI manufacturers or suppliers. This forum is meant to be a communication channel for process engineers, not salesmen. Please sav
Electronics Forum | Tue Jun 21 09:06:02 EDT 2005 | pci
Although I am sure that some of the postings here > are legitimate, it is obvious that many of them > have been written by AOI manufacturers or > suppliers. This forum is meant to be a > communication channel for process engineers, not > salesm
