Printed Circuit Board Assembly & PCB Design SMT Electronics Assembly Manufacturing Forum

Printed Circuit Board Assembly & PCB Design Forum

SMT electronics assembly manufacturing forum.

soldering books


soldering books | 5 May, 2000

Looking for the best choice in books on soldering processes, primarily reflow but wave is going to be with us for a while so.....

If you had to buy one today, which would you start with?

Here's the list I gleened from the archives:

Coombs, CF, "Printed Circuits Handbook" |

Lea, C, "A Scientific Guide To Surface Mount Technology"

Klein Wassink, RJ, "Soldering In Electronics"

Rahn, A, "The Basics Of Soldering" Woodgate, RW, "The Handbook Of Machine Soldering"

Jenny Hwang, "Modern Solder Technology for Competitive Electronics Manufacturing"

Rudolph Strauss, "SMT Soldering Handbook, Second Edition"

Any additions?

Thanks, guys.

reply »


Re: soldering books | 6 May, 2000

Hi Steve: Easy question, Klein Wassink is THE BOOK. It is head and shoulders above the others.

Coombs: Very good book, focused primarily on board fab with some discussion on assembly. Lea: A dated, once very good book. Rahn: Average book. Actually, in this group it's below average. Woodgate: I love the philosophy and approach, but it's far from current. Hwang: Great on materials properties, weak on soldering. I'd buy the McGraw-Hill version, rather than the Electrochemical Publications version. Strauss: Haven't read it, but I chose to buy Judd over Strauss recently.

Other suggestions: * Judd "Soldering In Electronic Assembly" 2nd E, Newnes, (0750635452) ... Very good book, kinda Brit oriented, wierd that Cookson sponsored it (even though there is no offensive adverts) * Manko "Solders & Soldering" 3rd E, van Nordstrond (0442264232) ... if K-Wassink is the god of soldering, then Manko is the god-father. Very good book.

I'd buy K-Wassink. If I couldn't pony up the $$$, I'd buy Judd to answer your question. Then, I'd buy Coombs, Then, I'd buy Hwang. Then, I'd buy Manko. But, I'm leaving-out Woodgate, so he sorta has to get mashed in there somewhere, depending on your need to think of making a good solder connection as a system.

Happy soldering Dave F

reply »


Now, to find a source.... | 8 May, 2000

Thanks Dave. Figured you'd come through on that one.

Any recommendations for a source, and for other good reading as well? Found a Brit site, but would like to avoid international shipping costs if possible......

Thanks again.


reply »


Re: Now, to find a source.... | 8 May, 2000

Hello Steve Most of these are available from the SMTA bookstore in Minnesota. 612/920-7682 There is a discount if you are a member and they offer free UPS ground shipping. Cast my vote for Klein-Wassink John Thorup

reply »


Re: Now, to find a source.... | 8 May, 2000

Thanks, John. I'm either in need of a vacation, or we need to clean the filters on our air handling system again. The last two books I bought were through that site and I didn't even think of it. Sheesh.

reply »


Re: Now, to find a source.... | 8 May, 2000

Steve: A couple years ago, I decided that I needed to broaden my education in the areas(s) that I make my livelihood � soldering and assembly. I had attended some excellent (and some not so excellent) tutorials at NECON, but just felt I was missing so much. So, every other month I buy AND READ a book related to the business that I love and that feeds me and my family � electronic assembly.

So that gets us to the next problem � the point of your question � "How do I know which books are good?" "Books are expensive, which are worth the money?" "And how can I buy them as inexpensively as possible?" The final element of the problem � "I�ve read all the books I ever wanted to read in college / I don�t read / I�m so whipped by the time I get home, I all I want to do is watch Whoopie / etc etc" is something you should talk to someone else about.

Sorry to be repetitous, but the first and best screen, for me, is SMTA. They offer a wide range of topics that are screened by their reviewers (although some are getting a bit stale); better than average prices, especially for members; and good shipping response. If you buy a couple books a year and attend a meeting or two a year, that�ll pay for your membership, $75 or so. Plus you get a lapel pin!!!! Watttza lapel anywho? Finally in response to this part of your question, you�ll find THE BOOK at SMTA (

Second, SMTnet has started a new book review, on-line talk to the author series that debuts in May. (I know it�s May now, chill it's coming) I have reviewed C Harper "Electronic Packaging & Interconnect Handbook." Wolfgang is doing a J Lau book on flip chips (I believe) in June (I believe). Periodically, Keith, at SMTnet, posts a itty, bitty, tiney, weenie, banner up near the top of the SMTnet page on this, as teaser. (Hey Keith, is this good PR er watt?)

Third, Brian Ellis, before he got frustrated with the very nice people that run SMTnet and left in disgust, reviewed some books in the news letter. They should be in the news letter archives. (I assume there is such a thing) Brian is the author of a book on board cleaning published by Electrochemical Publications � same as THE BOOK and other books focused on electronic assembly.

Forth, continuing with SMTnet, they have probably the broadest and longest list of industry books out there, many with extensive reviews attached.

Fifth, Bob Willis, who also used to participate on SMTnet, published his top ten. Bob Willis' Top Ten: "Microelectronics Packaging Handbook," Tummala and Rymaszewski, Van Nostrand Reinhold "Solders and Soldering," Manko, HH, McGraw Hill "SMT for PC Board Design," Hollomon, J, Howard W. Sams "Soldering in Electronics," Klein Wassink, Electrochemical Publications "Printed Circuit Handbook," Coombs Jr, C, McGraw Hill "Handbook of Printed Circuit Design, Manufacture, Components & Assembly," Leonida, G, Electrochemical Publications 1981 "Ball Grid Array Technology," Lau, J, McGraw Hill "Flexible Circuit," Fjelstad, J, Electrochemical Publications "Quality Assessment of Printed Circuit Boards," Lund, P, Bishop Graphics "Scientific Guide to Surface Mount Technology," Lea, C, Electrochemical Publications

Sixth, anything that Jim Blankenhorn lists on SMT Plus is good.

Seventh, try Computer Literacy. Their site is bighead or something like that, look it up.

Eighth, try the sites of professional societies (ie, ASQC, IEEE, ASME, ASM), they will recommend top flight books.

Nineth, try the sites of professional groups (ie, IPC, EOS/ESD), they will recommend top flight books.

Tenth, many of these books are available from the online book sellers (ie, amazon, bn, borders)

Finally, if you�re really cheap (like me), and don�t mind having a book that�s not the latest and greatest edition and may be a little shop worn, buy a used book. Search on the sites yourself � that�s my home.

Good luck Dave F

reply »


Re: Now, to find a source.... | 9 May, 2000

Don't ever leave, Dave.

reply »

2023 IPC Certification Training Schedule Eptac

Electronics Equipment Consignment